Brothers in War
Hi Charlie, my dad served in the Vietnam War and said that the only movie that accurately depicted his experience in Vietnam is "Platoon". The movie helped open the door for him to finally feel ready to talk about his experiences. My family only received bits and pieces at first but now he talks pretty openly about it. He even just heard from a guy in Michigan, this past July, that served in one of the platoons that his platoon worked with while he was there. He was extremely happy to hear from him. This guy told him that there is another guy that was in his platoon that wrote a book about a battle that they all fought in--Tam Ky. The title of the book is "Tam Ky-The Battle for Nui Yon Hill". My dad said the book is accurate. I just want to thank you for everything you do to support all of our veterans and thank you for all your efforts to tell the story of what happened in Vietnam.
I truly feel like I was born in the wrong era. The stories of Vietnam capture me and continue to pull on my inner soul...These men...these heroes are more then soldiers...they are men of Valor.
I watched this documentary last Saturday. John Young, from West St. Paul, Minnesota was one of the men featured. He is a high school classmate of mine. At our fiftieth class reunion last September he told us about the book, The Boys of '67. and the upcoming documentary. We were notified about the airing. I plan to watch it again on Wednesday. These men are heroes in spite of the unpopular war status. The film gives praise to their service and action in war. They are commended for their efforts and courage. We did lose two of our classmates in that war and this is a memorial to them along with their names on the Wall in Washington, DC.
This is a documentary that every American should see. Thanks to N.G. for presenting such a well-rounded and respectful representation of those who served in Vietnam.
I've recently returned from a trip to Ft. Campbell with my father, a Vietnam veteran, for a military ceremony which honored veterans through active-duty soldiers. Many of these men gave their lives, including my father's best friend (and my Godfather) who was killed in Vietnam.
I believe that this film has come at a time when veterans and civilians alike are more ready to examine the deep-complexities of this war.
In particular, it's time for all of us to more deeply understand and honor the level of bravery and sacrifice of those who served in Vietnam. This recognition should then be joined with the commitment of every American to never again turn our backs on our troops, no matter what our personal beliefs may be.
I was a medic with A company of the 9th. I was at Fort Riley and went over on the ship with Charlie company in 1967. I was stationed in camp Bearcat. I'm glad to see that their story made it to the screen so people will finally know the whole story about Vietnam.
Outstanding documentary!!! I grew up during that era and lost some classmates over there. Having lived in Central KS, we are all very familiar with Fort Riley so this piece hit close to home.
Having served in the 9th ID, 3/34th 105mm Artillery Battery C, Mobile Riverine Force on the barges (Sept.1968- July 1969 gun 3,4) and inland supporting the Infantry's needs of fire power it was interesting to see their side of the equation.
Ah how I miss Capt. Wood and never got a chance to thank him for busting me to Corporal, turned out to be a great favor!
Especially thanks to the nearby INFANTRY GI's who frequently guarded our perimeter in KLAW. They were on PROFILE (?) with, mainly, jungle rot on their lower extremities due to hours in the water of the rice patties. Your additional security on our perimeter, while we were busy with fire missions each night, for your pals, WAS APPRECIATED!
WELCOME HOME ALL
I was very impressed and honored to watch this documentary. I came up in the 70's and remembered watching on TV things going on in Vietnam plus the caskets, so many caskets of the boys coming home plus the reunions of the men with their families.
Terry McBride was just like my neighbor 'Shotgun' who served in 1965-1969 Special Forces 101st Airborne Green Beret. Shotgun would have done the same thing to that prisoner that Mr. McBride did. That VC did not deserve to ride with his friend. I am glad he did what he did. The VC did a lot worse to us, that everybody has seemed to forgotten conveniently.
These men deserve our utmost respect and a thanking them with a handshake of doing their job and doing it well. Too many have been shunned because of it not being a 'popular' war. It doesn't matter, they did what they where called to do and believed in what they where doing was right.
I would like to be able to say 'Thank You' to all who served in whatever capacity in this war (not a conflict) and know there are some of us out there that are very grateful to you and your families.
My father was in Charlie Company, I am speechless, and proud to be his son. This program was more insightful and made me think How lucky I was to be born. My dad survived came back to the world and started a family...Thanks Dad!
His name is
Frank J Lopez 67-68 Charlie Co 9 ID
Incredibly well restored footage of the river war and the horrors of combat. I served as cox'n on Tango 112-11 Feb-Aug 1968. Many of us on the boats thought the Army had it worse than the Navy boat crews; the grunts hated being on the boats because they felt so vulnerable to ambushes while enroute to the operating areas. (We lost a full platoon within five seconds on August 18, 1968.) On that day I was wounded and medevac'd home.
Well done Lou Reda Productions and National Geographic.
Author: Muddy Jungle Rivers : A River Assault Boat Cox'n's Memory Journey of His War in Vietnam and Return Home
I'm a recent college graduate of Penn State University and studied a lot about the Vietnam War while obtaining my bachelor degree. This documentary was simply astonishing and shows who the real heroes of our nation are. It was very moving and educational, yet showing the harsh realties of war. I just wanna say thanks to all the veterans for fighting for our freedom. Freedom comes at a very gruesome cost, but charlie company made that sacrifice. God Bless you guys.
I was in the Mobile Riverine Force attached with the 9TH ID. from 11/67-11/68 and was wounded 4 April 1968. This i believe will be the first doc. depicting the Navy and Army's Riverine's which were a very specialized unit and I am sure the National Geographic Channel will portray our service to our country with accuracy and respect
News on the broadcast of this special program.
According to a reliable source, National Geographic plans on showing it Wednesday, March 26 at 20:00 hours / 8pm :)
It will make you feel as if you are right there, prepare for that.
I have seen the 2+ hour rough cut of the production back in July of 13. It is terrific from beginning to end, no hollywood B/S. All original footage, well cleaned up,formatted for HD. The sound is equally good, as are the interviews form 12 of the men that were there for that year.It will feel as though you are there with the men,so be warned,the realisim is extraordinary .We will see about 88 mins. when the final cut is made.
USS Constellation CVA-64
Dear Sam Johnson, as an FYI.... we totally lucked out that one of our ole Charlie Company troopers (John Young) inadvertently became friends with the noted historian/author Dr. Andrew Wiest and that Dr. Wiest chose to spend six years of his life writing a book about us. And amazingly enough, National Geographic chose to create a documentary based on the book. To a man, every 4th/47th ole trooper I've communicated with who has Dr. Wiest's book, "The Boy's of '67" tell me that though it's covers Charlie Company it's really about what we all experienced. I, for one, am most grateful to Dr. Wiest and National Geographic for keeping our unit's exploits alive. We shall never forget our fallen. Big kudos go to Lou Reda Productions for their outstanding work creating "Brothers in War" and remembering us. www.9thinfantrydivision.com
John Young,in this photo at the wall, is my brother. This program was actually filmed because of a book that was written about Charlie Company, called "The Boys of '67". You simply must read it if you are a veteran of the war or if you have family who was. The author is Andrew Weist. Dr, Weist teaches at the University of Southern MS in Hattiesburg. One of his classes is on the Viet Nam war. He met my brother, John, through the V.A. in Gulfport as he wanted to write about PTSD. After meeting my brother, John asked if he could sit in on the class and Dr. Weist said, "No, but you can team teach with me." And so it began . . . .
Why do they never show any thing for Aco/4/47it is always about Charlie co
We were the mobile marine force aka River Rats
Aco was in one of the worse battles in the Mekong delta on 6/19/1967
We lost most of our originals on that day in one battle don't forget about A co
@Becky Sands I just googled this to watch it today ... Memorial Day ... and the full documentary is on youTube.
@Becky Sands I was searching around to watch this today ... Memorial Day ... and found it on youTube. The entire documentary.
@Bill Brinton I was Navy and served on A-111-3 and M-92-1, MRF, May 68-June 69. We had to work together to be successful, and we did. This video was well done, indeed.
WELCOME HOME BROTHER.
@Lou Lesc I was Navy and served on A-111-3. On occasion, we would escort the "arty barges" upriver to their firebase location, usually on river by a small village. The mess barge food was way better than ship food. We use to call this op "Hash and Trash".
WELCOME HOME BROTHER
@Wendell Affield I rode A-111-3 May68-June69. My boat probably led you upriver on occasion.
WELCOME HOME BROTHER.
@William Reynolds Bill, Steve Heffner here. I was one of the editors who worked on the show with Liz. I cannot wait to meet you guys in person this March!
@Sam Johnson Dad to be honest if you want stories told about Alpha Co you and hand full of men that survived need to tell your story... I and others will never know what you went thur until your story is told.
Daddy I am honored you served.. I serve your brothers in arms everyday at work you have given me a huge heart to care for my Vets in a way no other nurse can.. Thank you
love you always
Mr. Johnson, what took place on 06/19/1967 is in the production, what happened to A co. when it was over, is covered, not alot though, the magnatude of your ordeal that is told is quite endearing sir. Your brothers will never be forgotten, America will now know.
I offer a salute to A co. I will never forget.
@Sam Johnson Hey Sam. From rumors I've heard, June 19 is covered and there is a sequence devoted to Aco and the losses they took.
I will be looking for you sir at the event. It will be an honor to be among so many other " Brother's in War "
@S H Correction... we have 160 Charlie Company troopers/family/friend coming to DC next week & we are cranked for an outstanding Charlie Company reunion with Nat Geo & Lou Reda Productions!